“They did something similar before” – prior acts, character, and self-defense

In a recent (October, 2019) manslaughter trial in Philadelphia, the jury heard a lot about the victim, information not limited to conduct at the time of the fight that led to his death.  The jury heard, as an early defense witness, a bartender from Florida.  Although the death occurred in 2018, the jury heard about

Reflections on a Wrongful Conviction

The joke for criminal defense lawyers, such as it is, is the response to the question “how do you represent guilty people?”  The answer/punchline is “that’s easy; it’s representing someone who is actually innocent that causes nightmares.”  You may ‘lose the case,’ but your client loses freedom. As the original trial lawyer for Willie Veasy,

Rule 106: Know The Rest Of The Story – In Real Time

Everyone has seen words taken out of context, and thus given new and unintended meaning. Consider the movie review that reads “nothing about this film is excellent.” What ends up in the advertisement? “Daily Journal says ’excellent.’” What happens in advertising or political chicanery has no place in the courtroom, and Rule 106 is intended

CRIME…OR HOSPITAL CARE MISINTERPRETED?

When a child dies and there are signs of physical abnormalities—bruises, tearing, etc.—the result may be testimony of “unquestionable” or “unmistaken” signs of sexual abuse. That in turn may lead to criminal prosecution, conviction, and even a sentence of death. Yet both the advance of science and the simple act of paying greater attention to